Dear Parents,
A recent Forbes piece by Christopher Rim announces that the most selective colleges have moved on from the “pointy” applicant, the kid with one defining passion pursued since middle school, and now want “star shaped” students who blend interests that rarely overlap. His examples are a computer science student who combines coding with linguistics to preserve a heritage dialect, and a public health applicant whose urban design work revealed how neighborhood layouts shape access to care. These are great examples, sure. But do colleges actually think this way? Are admissions teams sitting around sorting applicants by shape? I will agree that the kid who is too perfect, too consistent, and too parent driven is a problem, especially next to a kid who is more authentically themselves, something I try to cultivate in the students I work with.
Ivy League schools are not looking for applications that fit into a geometric pattern. They are looking for the next great inventors and thinkers to help solve the problems of our world, plain and simple: students who genuinely think.
“Top colleges want young people who read widely, make connections across disciplines, and show that ideas matter to them.”
If I were an admissions officer at an Ivy League school reading Rim’s article, my reaction would be: seriously? That advice doesn’t say anything. Every few years the ideal applicant gets rebranded: well rounded, then pointy, now star shaped. Each new label sells anxious parents a formula, and the real kid gets lost.
I earned my master’s at Columbia, lived on Yale’s campus for years, and studied for a semester at Harvard. Along the way, I came to know the kinds of students who thrive in those places. What they share is not a profile built to get in. They are smart, self driven intellectuals who want to do something important because they are genuinely fascinated by the field they are pursuing. No big college consulting firm can produce that.
The institutions themselves tell us what they value. Stanford names “intellectual vitality” as a core criterion. Harvard’s supplement asks applicants to describe an intellectual experience that mattered to them. Columbia asks students to list the texts, resources, and outlets that have shaped their intellectual development, a question that cannot be answered convincingly by someone who does not read. Yale asks what college course a student would teach, what book they would write, or what original art they would create. Every one of these prompts tests the same thing: does this person think, and does that thinking show up in how they live?
What distinguishes these students is not their shape but their literacy. E. D. Hirsch argued in Cultural Literacy (1987) that comprehension depends on shared background knowledge: a reader who knows history, literature, science, and the arts understands more of everything they encounter. The chemistry student who has read Primo Levi’s The Periodic Table sees her discipline as part of human experience, not merely a lab exercise. The bass player who reads Camus and recognizes the absurd in a twelve bar blues progression is making exactly the kind of connection no consultant can script. A student who reads about the Dust Bowl and then notices how drought maps of the American West repeat that history is thinking across subjects. Those are the moments that surface in a strong essay, a thoughtful teacher recommendation, an interview, or a summer spent pursuing a question nobody assigned.
“We have to get kids caring about deep intellectual thought again, because that is precisely what top universities are looking for.”
The data points in the same direction. In NACAC’s State of College Admission reports, grades in college preparatory courses and the rigor of a student’s curriculum consistently rank as the most important factors in admission decisions, rated of “considerable importance” by roughly three quarters of colleges. Selective institutions want evidence of sustained intellectual engagement, and at schools admitting fewer than one in twenty applicants (Princeton recently reported a 4.0% admit rate), a packaged narrative is easy to spot. Admissions readers have seen thousands of strategically assembled profiles. What stands out is a mind at work.
Packaging teenagers to fit a trend isn’t what admissions officers want, nor what I want for kids. Some students are well rounded. Some are well lopsided. Some have many gifts and no clear through line yet. None of those is the wrong way to be fourteen or seventeen. A girl who loves chemistry and nothing else isn’t a problem to fix. Neither is a boy who plays bass, swims, and reads philosophy without knowing yet how any of it fits together.
We live in an era of instant connectivity, yet being connected is not the same as making connections. Information moves in seconds, while the work of linking ideas still happens slowly, inside a single mind. We have to get kids caring about deep intellectual thought again, because that is precisely what top universities are looking for. That slower habit is what I try to cultivate, and my favorite moments come when students make connections nobody assigned. One of my English students, reading Joyce’s A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, suddenly recognized Picasso in its pages, two artists reinventing how a single mind perceives the world. Another student, in a college essay, traced a similar thread through Einstein unsettling absolute time and World War I shattering Europe’s old order. Both had found an entire era losing faith in one fixed perspective, and few things delight me more than watching students make discoveries like that without being told. My work lives in moments like these: helping students think widely and deeply, carrying ideas across their lives out of intellectual curiosity rather than on a strategist’s orders. That kind of thinking can’t be engineered to fit the latest admissions trend. It happens slowly, through reading, conversation, travel, trial and error, and a lot of noticing.
So I start with simple questions. What do you want to be when you grow up? What sparks your interest right now? What kind of person are you becoming? Nobody needs a perfect answer. What matters is noticing the pattern: what excites them, what they keep returning to, where they show unusual focus, and where they might be capable of going deeper.
“What stands out is a mind at work.”
When a kid genuinely engages with the world, the interesting connections Rim describes happen on their own. You can’t manufacture curiosity. You can only cultivate it, and that takes years of paying attention, not a branding exercise in senior year.
Rim closes by saying an application should show how a student thinks and what they’ll bring to campus. Fine. But you don’t get there by picking a shape for your child. You get there by paying attention, year after year, until who they already are comes fully into view.
Sources
Christopher Rim, Forbes; Stanford University admission criteria; Harvard College and Columbia College supplemental prompts; Yale University supplemental prompts; NACAC, State of College Admission; Princeton University admissions statistics; E. D. Hirsch, Cultural Literacy (1987).
Questions parents ask
Frequently asked
- What do Ivy League schools actually want?
- They are looking for students who think: young people who read widely, make connections across disciplines, possess genuine cultural literacy, and demonstrate through their choices that ideas matter to them.
- What does it mean that colleges now want "star shaped" students?
- A recent Forbes piece by Christopher Rim announces that the most selective colleges have moved on from the "pointy" applicant, the kid with one defining passion pursued since middle school, and now want "star shaped" students who blend interests that rarely overlap. Every few years the ideal applicant gets rebranded: well rounded, then pointy, now star shaped. Each new label sells anxious parents a formula, and the real kid gets lost.
- How do colleges test whether a student really thinks?
- Stanford names "intellectual vitality" as a core criterion. Harvard's supplement asks applicants to describe an intellectual experience that mattered to them. Columbia asks students to list the texts, resources, and outlets that have shaped their intellectual development, a question that cannot be answered convincingly by someone who does not read. Yale asks what college course a student would teach, what book they would write, or what original art they would create.
- Do grades and course rigor still matter most?
- In NACAC's State of College Admission reports, grades in college preparatory courses and the rigor of a student's curriculum consistently rank as the most important factors in admission decisions, rated of "considerable importance" by roughly three quarters of colleges.
- What if my child is well rounded, or has one main interest, or has many gifts and no clear direction?
- Some students are well rounded. Some are well lopsided. Some have many gifts and no clear through line yet. None of those is the wrong way to be fourteen or seventeen. A girl who loves chemistry and nothing else isn't a problem to fix. Neither is a boy who plays bass, swims, and reads philosophy without knowing yet how any of it fits together.
- Can we build that kind of curiosity for an application?
- You can't manufacture curiosity. You can only cultivate it, and that takes years of paying attention, not a branding exercise in senior year.